Bakery
Pastry
Voted Best Bake Shop every year since 2017, all of our pastries are made-from-scratch daily. Flavors are determined each day by our incredible baking team.
Stop in to see what delicious flavor combinations have been created today.
SERVED DAILY
Cinnamon Rolls
Soft yeasted treat loaded with caramelized sugar and spicy aromatic cinnamon. Topped with vanilla glaze or rich & creamy cream cheese icing.
Danish
Hand laminated dough with plenty of butter and eggs to create a beautiful, flaky pastry.
French Toast Bake
Our version of a breakfast bread pudding. It is made with cinnamon rolls soaked in custard, rested overnight, and then baked with a crunchy streusel topping.
Muffins
Large, tender, and filled with a variety of fresh fruits, assorted chocolates, or spices and nuts. Gluten Free Friendly options are available daily.
Scones
Crunchy exterior with a pillowy soft center filled with juicy fruits, nuts, peanut butter, or chocolates.
Quiche
Savory custard baked in a flaky, crispy crust. The filling can be vegetarian or contain various meats.
AVAILABLE FRIDAY THROUGH SUNDAY
Pecan Rolls
Fresh cinnamon roll baked in a bed of caramelized chopped pecans.
Pop Starts
An amped up version of the favorite toaster pastry with a butter laden flaky crust filled with house made jam.
AVAILABLE BY SPECIAL ORDER
If you need large quantities of any of the above menu items, click here to place a Special Order Request
Dessert
Treat yourself to a made-from-scratch dessert.
SERVED DAILY
Brownies
Rich, fudgy bar either plain or with delicious mix-ins and sometimes topped with our delicious buttercream.
Cake Truffles
Combination of cake and buttercream icing that is dipped in chocolate (think cake pop without the stick).
Cheesecake
Large, single serving of dense filling either plain, freshly made fruit toppings or seasonal flavors.
Cookies
Salted chocolate chip, peanut butter, snickerdoodle, and shortbread.
Shortbread is plain, chocolate, or chocolate & caramel. Seasonal flavors also available.
Cupcakes
Delicious cake and buttercream available as Chocolate, Vanilla or specialty flavors including Carrot Cake,
Red Velvet, Lemon, Cookie Dough, Strawberries & Cream, German Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Toffee, and Tiramisu.
Fruit Bars & Tarts
Seasonal fruit flavors served either on a shortbread style crust or a buttery tart pie crust.
Peanut Butter Pie
Slightly sweet, peanut butter filling in a single serve crust.
Gluten-Free Friendly (GFF) Dessert
Food identified as Gluten-Free Friendly was prepared without gluten in the same kitchen and with the same equipment as
food containing gluten. Fresh Start Café & Bakery cannot guarantee there is no risk of cross-contamination.
Buckeye Bars
Consist of a peanut butter layer covered with chocolate. Think traditional ‘buckeyes’ created in a bar form.
Coconut Macaroons
Coconut cookies that are soft, sweet, chewy on the inside and slightly crunchy on the outside. Served plain or dipped in chocolate.
Energy Squares
Moist shortbread crust topped with an assortment of seeds, nuts, and dried fruit.
AVAILABLE BY SPECIAL ORDER
If you need large quantities of any of the above menu items, click here to place a Special Order Request
Cakes & Special Orders
Minimum 3 Day Notice Required
Larger quantities of any of our pastries and/or desserts can be scheduled by special order. In addition, we can make the following:
Cakes
6” Double-Layer (serves 4-6)
8” Double-Layer (serves 10-12)
Available flavors: vanilla, chocolate, carrot cake, cookie dough, red velvet,
toffee, tiramisu, lemon, naked, peanut butter, German chocolate, chocolate ganache.
¼ Sheet Cake (serves 18-24)
½ Sheet Cake (serves 36-48)
Available flavors: vanilla and chocolate.
Bread
Brownie Cakes
Brownie Tray
Cheesecake (whole)
Cobbler
Coffeecake
Cookie Cakes
Cookie Tray
Cupcakes
Dessert Tray
Peanut Butter Pie (whole)
Pound Cake
Gluten-Free Friendly (GFF) Cakes & Special Orders
*Please be advised that food identified as Gluten-Free Friendly was prepared with gluten in the same kitchen and with the same equipment as food containing gluten. Fresh Start Café & Bakery cannot guarantee there is no risk of cross-contamination.
Bread
Brownies
Cake
Cheesecake
Cupcakes
Special Order Request Form
PLEASE FILL OUT THE FORM BELOW AND WE WILL CONTACT YOU within 24 hours.
Quantities of any of our pastries and/or desserts can be requested by special order. Minimum 3 day notice required.